Roofing Report USASee #1 Pick

Home / Florida / Central Florida

Independent Roofing Research

Top Rated Roofing Companies in Central Florida

#1 RANKED WINNERBest Overall Value

Stronghold Roofing

Central Florida · Best Overall Value

Overall score

94 /100

Price lower than 98.7% of Florida roofers
View Roofers Website (866) 452-0105
Real estimate provided
Customer reviews
471Reviews

4.8 out of 5 stars

Licensing
Verified

Research-submitted · not independently checked

Insurance
Verified

Research-submitted · not independently checked

Estimated 1,500 sq. ft. architectural shingle replacement. Final pricing varies by project.

8 years in businessSubmitted research

Why Stronghold Wins

#1 OVERALL

The strengths behind its top position in this report.

  • Highest combined score on our two most heavily weighted factors: price and reviews.
  • Competitive pricing relative to other evaluated contractors.
  • Strong, consistent customer review profile.
  • Established presence serving Central Florida communities.

Winning strengths

  • WINNERBest Pricing #1
  • WINNERBest Warranty · 25+ Years
  • WINNERStrong review profile
  • WINNERStrong overall value

Best Pricing and Best Warranty are research-selected distinctions, not independently established comparisons. The 25+ year warranty is research-submitted; coverage and terms have not been independently reviewed.

Materials

  • Shingle
  • Metal
  • Tile
  • Flat
View Roofers Website (866) 452-0105
#2

K.L. Smith

Overall score

90 /100

Real estimate provided
Customer reviews
322Reviews

4.9 out of 5 stars

Licensing
Verified

Research-submitted · not independently checked

Insurance
Verified

Research-submitted · not independently checked

Estimated 1,500 sq. ft. architectural shingle replacement. Final pricing varies by project.

38 years in businessSubmitted research
View Roofers Website (863) 500-7609
#3

Musick Roofing

Overall score

89 /100

Real estimate provided
Customer reviews
240Reviews

4.9 out of 5 stars

Licensing
Verified

Research-submitted · not independently checked

Insurance
Verified

Research-submitted · not independently checked

Estimated 1,500 sq. ft. architectural shingle replacement. Final pricing varies by project.

20 years in businessSubmitted research
View Roofers Website (863) 904-5350
#4

CFL Roofing

Overall score

88 /100

Real estimate provided
Customer reviews
386Reviews

4.8 out of 5 stars

Licensing
Verified

Research-submitted · not independently checked

Insurance
Verified

Research-submitted · not independently checked

Estimated 1,500 sq. ft. architectural shingle replacement. Final pricing varies by project.

10 years in businessSubmitted research
View Roofers Website (407) 917-7663
#5

Thomas Roofing of Central Florida

Overall score

87 /100

Real estimate provided
Customer reviews
355–376Reviews

4.9 out of 5 stars

Licensing
Verified

Research-submitted · not independently checked

Insurance
Verified

Research-submitted · not independently checked

Estimated 1,500 sq. ft. architectural shingle replacement. Final pricing varies by project.

18 years in businessSubmitted research
View Roofers Website (352) 625-7663
#6

Eustis Roofing – Lakeland

Overall score

85 /100

Real estimate provided
Customer reviews
155Reviews

4.8 out of 5 stars

Licensing
Verified

Research-submitted · not independently checked

Insurance
Verified

Research-submitted · not independently checked

Estimated 1,500 sq. ft. architectural shingle replacement. Final pricing varies by project.

9 years in businessSubmitted research
View Roofers Website (352) 744-5983

Compare Our Top Picks

Prices and overall scores reflect the confirmed figures submitted for this report. Estimates use a 1,500 sq. ft. architectural shingle replacement scenario; final project costs vary. Licensing and insurance documentation has not been independently reviewed by this platform.

CompanyPriceScore
#1Stronghold Roofing471 reviews · 4.8 ★$13.5k942.K.L. Smith322 reviews · 4.9 ★$16.3k903.Musick Roofing240 reviews · 4.9 ★$15.8k894.CFL Roofing386 reviews · 4.8 ★$17.5k885.Thomas Roofing of Central Florida355–376 reviews · 4.9 ★$18.4k876.Eustis Roofing – Lakeland155 reviews · 4.8 ★$19.3k85

How We Rank Roofing Companies

Every company is evaluated on the same 12 factors, applied in this order of priority.

01

Price

02

Reviews

03

Licensing

04

Insurance

05

Experience

06

Complaints

07

Warranty

08

Reputation

09

Responsiveness

10

Transparency

11

BBB

12

Locality

What We Check

Status for our #1 ranked company. Research-submitted verification is labeled separately from independently confirmed records.

Pricing

Checked

Customer Reviews

Checked

State Licensing

Verified (research-submitted)

Insurance

Verified (research-submitted)

Research-submitted; documentation not independently reviewed.

Complaint History

Pending

Years in Business

Pending

Warranty Coverage

Pending

BBB Standing

Pending

Local Presence

Checked

Company Transparency

Pending

About This Report

Region
Central Florida
Companies Evaluated
6
Research Factors
12
Last Updated
October
Methodology
Roofing Report USA Ranking Methodology

This report helps homeowners compare established roofing companies operating throughout Central Florida using one consistent, published framework.

Frequently Asked Questions